Welcome to Lillo's Tomato Pies
Located in Hainesport, NJ, Lillo's Tomato Pies offers a variety of mouth-watering dishes ranging from their signature 18" Tomato Pie to specialty pies like Buffalo Chicken and Clams Casino. Their Cheesesteaks, made with premium steak and Cooper Sharp cheese, are also a must-try. With options for delivery, takeout, and reservations, Lillo's provides a casual dining experience perfect for groups. The diverse menu caters to both meat lovers and vegetarians, ensuring there's something for everyone. Enjoy a delicious meal at Lillo's Tomato Pies and indulge in their flavorful creations.
- 2503 Marne Hwy Hainesport, NJ 080362503 Marne Hwy Hainesport, NJ 08036 Hotline: (609) 491-7751
Lillo's Tomato Pies is a casual dining spot located in Hainesport, NJ, offering a variety of delicious options such as burgers, pizza, and sandwiches. This restaurant not only provides delivery and takeout services but also takes reservations, making it convenient for diners looking to enjoy a tasty meal.
One of the standout items on their menu is the Tomato Pie, a classic dish that can be customized with additional toppings for an extra charge. In addition, Lillo's Tomato Pies features a selection of Specialty Pies including the flavorful Buffalo Chicken Pie, the unique Cauliflower Crust Pie, and the indulgent Nonna Pie, among others.
If you're in the mood for a cheesesteak, Lillo's Tomato Pies has you covered with options like the traditional Cheesesteak with premium steak and Cooper sharp cheese, or the Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak for a spicy twist. With a diverse menu offering something for everyone, Lillo's Tomato Pies is a great choice for groups looking to enjoy a satisfying meal together.
Personally, I have had the opportunity to try the Tomato Pie at Lillo's Tomato Pies and I must say, it exceeded my expectations. The crust was perfectly crispy, the sauce was flavorful, and the toppings were fresh and abundant. I also had the chance to sample the Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak, which was incredibly tasty and had just the right amount of heat.
Overall, my experience at Lillo's Tomato Pies was fantastic and I highly recommend giving them a try if you're in the area. With their convenient location, diverse menu, and delicious offerings, Lillo's Tomato Pies is sure to become a favorite among food lovers.

I've been wanting to try Lilos for a while, so it was a nice surprise to come across today on my way home. I've had a lot of great steaks, but this was the best one I've ever had. It was flavorful, sliced thin, and chopped fine, which is my preference. The roll was delicious. It was solid enough to stand up to the steak but also nice and soft inside. The cheese was melted all the way through, and the cherry peppers added a great spice to the sandwich. I didn't even try to put ketchup on it. The garlic spread was a unique and delicious touch that I feel really sets them apart. 10/10 for me.

Excellent. My wife got the chicken cheesesteak. I got a slice of sausage and a huge garden salad. The salad came with exploding cherry tomatoes, cheese and artichokes. I got a cheese steak to go. Phenomenal food. Great customer service. Also, functioning and clean bathroom. ***Pro tip*** bring cash. They do take credit but there is a 3.5% discount for cash and small business always prefer it

My third try coming here after showing up too late the last couple times after the rolls were gone for the day, I’m glad I finally decided to get moving early! All I can saw is WOW. Definitely the best cheesesteak in the area, a wonderful slice of pizza and friendly folks working here, including the owner who stopped to chat for a few minutes. I’ll be back and it won’t be soon enough! Edited May 2025, everything I said above is still valid, I love this place!

Nice food. Pretty busy, kind of loud - was a bit hard to hear the cashier, kind of warm, lot of flies. People warned me not to get a large cheese steak, get the normal size one. Didn't look like they're sizes on the menu. Got the 16 oz, was a lot but okay. Seeded roll. Tomato pie was nice, had onion and green pepper. Onion was sweet. Though I think maybe it was a bit over hypered. Was expecting it to blow me away or something, but it's just a good pie. Google maps tells you to pull around the streets with a bunch of right turns if you're coming from the west, but you can just make a left I to the parking lot. Two Pokemon go pokestops here. Slices seem to be 3-4.5 per slice. Red sauce slices are better than white slices. Plain or old fashioned are pretty nice.

Busy and popular place mostly for pizza and cheesesteak. Highly ranked in cheesesteak reviews. Lots of families, pick up phone or take out.

Fantastic. The cheesesteak was phenomenal, if you love cheese, this cheesesteak will have the best cheese to meat ratio. The meat alone was fresh, definitely was not too chopped up but in great pieces in eat bite. The seeded roll had great texture and the onions were oddly large, but I did not mind it. The pizza is great, the pie ordered had a lot of tomato sauce but that isn’t a big issue. The crust was fantastic and towards the end of the slice, it was super crispy and that’s how it should be. I would definitely come back for the cheesesteak alone.

The cheesesteak and pie were absolutely delicious. The son Lilo was there, and gave us free French fires and ice cream because we came last year and they ran out of hero’s for their cheesesteaks. If you do not go to this place, you are making the biggest mistake of your life. Will go here every time I pass by. Thanks Lilo

Outstanding mustard pie Cheesesteaks were huge..with Cooper Delicious We got our food to go. Only a few tables if you were wanting to sit inside. Friendly staff. Very busy on a Saturday at lunch. The dining area could use a good cleaning. Food is fabulous though. Get it to go